[Verse 1 : Olivia, Elana]
I don't hit you back, you say, "How your night go?"
Wonder where you're at, yesterday was simple
You cannot attach, meet me in the middle
Feelin' over fact, no good for my mental
You don't hit me back, got me feelin' psycho
Don't know how to act, I'm about to spiral
Wanna be relaxed, but you keep actin' single
Feelin' over fact, for you, it don't come natural

[Pre-Chorus: Makhyi]
You think you're keepin' it secret (Keepin' it secret)
But I know you better
I hear your footsteps, you're creepin', yeah (You're creepin', yeah)
You should know better

[Chorus: Lillian]
Why do you tiptoe?
You know that I know
Why do you tiptoe?
Why do you tiptoe?
Why do you tiptoe, why?
You know that I don't
Why do you tiptoe, why?
Why do you slip all the time?
[Verse 2: Queenie]
I don't wanna stress
Got me feelin' emotionally possessed
Wish it was placebo
Can't let go unless you let go your ego
Ready to invest, if you're with it, then let me know

[Pre-Chorus: Makhyi]
You think you're keepin' it secret (Keepin' it secret)
But I know you better
I hear your footsteps, you're creepin', yeah (You're creepin', yeah)
You should know better

[Chorus: Lillian]
Why do you tiptoe?
You know that I know (I know)
Why do you tiptoe?
Why do you tiptoe?
Why do you tiptoe, why?
You know that I don't (I)
Why do you tiptoe, why?
Why do you slip all the time?

[Bridge: All]
Ooh, all the time
Ooh, all the time
[Verse 3: Makhyli]
I could be doin' you how you be doin' me
I could be makin' you number two outta, like, two or three
Why you be actin' like it's you and you?
What happened to you and me?
I could be wild here, actin' a fool
Instead, I'll be playin' it cool

[Chorus: All]
Why do you?
Why do you tiptoe? (Tiptoe, ah)
You know that I know (I know, I know)
Why do you tiptoe? (Why?)
Why do you tiptoe? (Why do you tiptoe?)
Why do you tiptoe, why?
You know that I don't (I don't)
Why do you tiptoe, why? (Why?)
Why do you slip all the time?