[Verse 1]
I thought that I was in love 'til I met you
But now I find that I'm in love with two

[Pre-Chorus]
Won back hope 'cause she's so sweet to me ('Cause she's so sweet to me)
And you right here, you love me tenderly (You love me tenderly)

[Chorus]
Which one should I choose?
Should it be her, should it be you?

[Verse 2]
I tried to be true to you, and I see you every day
And I tried to be true to her too, even though she's far away

[Pre-Chorus]
Girl, I'm just about to go out of my mind (About to lose my mind)
'Cause both of you girls are so doggone fine (About to lose my mind)

[Chorus]
Which one should I choose?
Should it be her, should it be you?

[Bridge]
(Which one should I choose?
Which one?
Which one should I choose?
Which one?
[Pre-Chorus]
If I lose either one, my heart's gonna break (My heart is gonna break)
Lord knows it's just too much for me to take (Too much for to take)

[Chorus]
Hey, which one should I choose?
Should it be her, should it be you?

Which one should I choose?
Should it be her, should it be you?
(Which one?)

Hey, which one should I choose?
Tell me baby, should it be her, or should it be you?
(Should it be her, should it be you?
Which one?
Which one should I choose?)