[Verse: Phineas, Isabella, Baljeet]
How could we be naughty when I thought we'd been so nice?
Could we have been blinded to some little hidden vice?
Did our visions of sugarplums not dance like they should?
I'm rackin' my brain here, I really thought we were good

[Pre-Chorus: All]
I know you got that list
And I know you check it twice
But could you check it again 'cause it seems to me
We were all pretty nice

[Chorus: All, Phineas & Isabella]
Where did we go wrong?
Please tell me
Where did we go wrong?
Where did we go
Won't somebody tell me?
Where did we go wrong?