[Verse 1]
I could not provide you with all that you needed
But it hurts me more
Knowing somebody else like me met those needs
And exceeded them, well, good for him
Trust me, I'm so happy you're together
And you feel the same way about him
I could write a million letters about this unique pain
So I did and then I shredded them (Ooh, oh, oh, ooh, mm)

[Verse 2]
I'm your little keepsake, stuff me in your shoe box
When he makes your heart ache, I'll be here to cry on
I would never judge you 'cause I'm already long numb
And I'll be here to cry to when he does you so wrong
Oh-oh, oh, ooh
Ooh-ooh, ooh, ooh, ooh

[Outro]
I could not provide you with all that you needed