[Verse 1: Avery Anna]
Lovin' you is like a rodeo
One day you're here and then you're gone
We go around just like a merry-go
And only you know when it stops

[Pre-Chorus: Avery Anna]
Well, shame on me
Wish my head would tell my heart what to think

[Chorus: Avery Anna & Matt Thomas]
Right when I need you the most
When I don't want it to end
When I don't want you to go
That's when I lose you again
Right when I think that you're mine
Right when I think you're all in
When we're too good for goodbye
That's when I lose you again

[Verse 2: Matt Thomas, Avery Anna & Matt Thomas]
They say when you love someone let 'em leave
I've gotten pretty good at that
That ain't the answer that I really need
It's what to do when they come back
[Pre-Chorus: Avery Anna & Matt Thomas, Avery Anna]
Do you forget, forgive like I do? Wish I didn't
If this is love then you're not in it

[Chorus: Avery Anna & Matt Thomas]
'Cause right when I need you the most
When I don't want it to end
When I don't want you to go
That's when I lose you again
Right when I think that you're mine
Right when I think you're all in
When we're too good for goodbye
That's when I lose you again, again

[Bridge: Avery Anna & Matt Thomas]
Break me to pieces or give me a reason
To believe you won't leave this time

[Chorus: Avery Anna & Matt Thomas, Avery Anna]
Right when I need you the most
When I don't want it to end
When I don't want you to go
That's when I lose you again
Right when I think that you're mine
Right when I think you're all in
When we're too good for goodbye
That's when I lose you again